It has been interesting reading up on other people’s responses to Julien Temple’s BBC 2 commissioned documentary Requiem For Detroit, not least from Detroiters themselves. There’s a real diversity and noticeable heterogeneity in the views. Here’s a cross-section of thoughts and links, for no better reason than sharing =)
More White Than Black
The Detroit Unreal Estate Agency’s Jimini Higgnet described the piece as Toothless and Incoherent, one in which the underlying racism contained within the city is further drawn out in the movie by the prevalence of white men telling a black man’s story and the propensity to portray the few blacks included in the footage in a very negative fashion.
As a dispassionate observer – who am I kidding? – I would like to see it differently. I think part of Higgnet’s argument holds weight but his response is a passionate and emotive one to a rather lop-sided storyline, told essentially by suburban whites and a full range of blacks from one end of the social spectrum to the other .
I think anyone could argue that certain angles in the story were heavily under-played, and that others such as the apocalyptic vision of Detroit are played up for the benefit of the argument. Everyone has an agenda ultimately, and only so much of a complete story can be told covering all bases.
Why Not ‘Requiem for Coventry’?
To some of the viewers in the UK, the documentary begged the question: why bother commissioning and sending Temple to Detroit to analyse the industrial past of the Motor City when the same effect could be viewed in any British industrial cityscape, Coventry for one, the once thriving home of the British motor industry.
No doubt if this was the case, the documentary may not have been as glamorous and equally Coventry couldn’t be described as the frontier of the motor industry nor the assembly line, taking its lead from Henry Ford and Company. In addition and even more breathtakingly is the sheer scale, not just of the city but of the exodus, and the stark social disparity amongst the city and the various suburbs, driving the story home even more. As a reporter friend of mine points out:
Detroit can’t really be compared to any other city. European places like Manchester got quite ragged but never lost their urban life. Other US places like Cleveland and Buffalo definitely got beat up, but Detroit is just incredibly extreme for a whole bunch of reasons involving race, bad government policy and the cozy decline of the auto industry from the 60s onwards, accelerated by the oil crisis of the 70s.
Iggy and The Stooges
Even Iggy Pop made his opinion known on the documentary itself – Iggy on Julien Temple’s Detroit Flick… - having been asked to participate by Temple:
Yeah. And he’s talented but he also has a particular style. And so I just couldn’t bring myself to do it. I just wasn’t a part of that. Not that I object to his expressing himself. But it’s a great place. Michigan is a great, great place. It really is.
And I would be inclined to agree with him. Why be inclined to focus on the purely negative when there is so much positive to focus on. Things could be a whole lot worse and Detroit does have much to offer, culturally and otherwise. It is not yet a ghost town and cultural wasteland.
Too Historical & Complex?
The documentary does a great job of driving home the ‘popular history’ history of Detroit, even if its means for doing so can be questioned, but as I said have said before, more interesting is the Detroit of today. The dichotomy. On one hand the ruins, the desperation, the scandal and the vast wastes of industrial wreckage, whilst on the other hand the totally functional side, the parts that give reason to love Detroit, not the totally dysfunctional ones.
All in all I wonder if the documentary actually adds value to our understanding, or does it do harm? I have probably answered this already, indirectly. I suppose what you take from it depends on your view point, but from my perspective it leaves much room for hope and inspiration, even if those on Time’s coverage of the film Requiem for Detroit less than palatable (view the comments):
As a life long resident of the suburbs of Detroit and current resident of the UK I was able to see the full length documentary this evening. I was both pleased and shocked (albeit not surprised) by the portrayal of the D in the documentary. I thought the film was a bit too artsy but did a good job citing certain aspects of the city. However, I felt it chose to discuss too many topics rather than focusing on few.
Ultimately, though, I think it proves the need for a proper safety net, and one in which more is done to help struggling post-industrials. It’s easy for companies to suck what they will out of a city and then close up shop, leaving whatever they will behind, but as a society, can and should we really let that happen? To this end Daniel Broughton’s blog on Social Policy and Thought, focused primarily on Detroit has some pretty interesting reading.
The More Recent Past
For those interested in the more recent past there is some interesting material published online that help open one’s eyes to the issues that have beset the city, it’s definitely well documented:
The Weekly Standard’s The City Where the Sirens Never Sleep, runs to 5 pages talking about the incompetence of the newly coined “Detroit Three” and the city-wide corruption of government officials:
Somewhere along the way, Detroit became our national ashtray, a safe place for everyone to stub out the butt of their jokes. This was never more evident than at the recent congressional hearings, featuring the heads of the Big Three automakers, now more often called the Detroit Three, as that sounds more synonymous with failure.
Bloomberg ran a piece The Fall of Detroit – An Insider’s View back in 2007 that looks at the decline from a more unique perspective, that of a retired auto plant worker, running through into the early 90s from the 60s:
That’s the hard part about being a former autoworker living near Detroit. Even though GM, Ford and Chrysler cut two-thirds of their employees in the past three decades, even though the Fleetwood and Willow Run assembly plants are gone and the UAW is a shadow of its former self, we’re not done paying for our mistakes.
Most succinctly of all though I think is Lowell Forest Boileau’s Fabulous Ruins of Detroit, which sums up the parlous state of the city in pictures, for they shout a thousand words, whilst the placard on his web site greets you:
Now, as for centuries, tourists behold those ruins with awe and wonder. Yet today, a vast and history laden ruin site passes unnoticed, even despised, into oblivion.
Really, there is so much great stuff out there online, and I still only scratch at the surface. No doubt there are pages I should have mentioned and haven’t, but I have been foraging furiously online soaking up as much as I could, and enjoying what I find, because ultimately I am intrigued and fascinated by the history and the present story of the city. I find so much beauty in it, even if the current sorry state of affairs seems like a veritable hell to some.